What Do New Gutters Cost, and What Moves That Number?

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – 25 years in Henry County · Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee and South Carolina



Most full-house gutter jobs we sell land between $2,500 and $4,500 — that is the real gutter cost on most houses. The midpoint is right around $3,400.

That isn’t a guess or an industry average. I went and pulled every gutter job we’ve sold this year across Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee and South Carolina — eighty of them, signed and approved — and that’s where they actually landed. Two thirds of them sat inside that $2,500 to $4,500 band. Those are our own records, not a survey.

The full spread ran from about $1,250 at the low end to $7,450 at the high end. Both of those are real houses.

Why Gutter Cost Spreads That Wide

Because a gutter price is mostly one piece of arithmetic and then a short list of decisions.

The arithmetic: new 6-inch gutter runs about $8.25 a foot installed — roughly $5 a foot of labor and $3.26 a foot of material. So the single biggest thing driving your number is how many feet of roofline you have. A small ranch and a two-story with a complicated roof are not close.

You can do this yourself in ten minutes. Walk the house and pace the roofline, or trace it on a satellite photo. Multiply by eight. That’s your starting number before anything else gets added, and it will put you within shouting distance of any honest quote.

What Gets Added On Top

Taking the old gutters off — about $2.86 a foot. Not every quote includes it, and it isn’t free.

Downspouts, and this is where quotes differ most. More on that below.

Leaf protection, which is its own decision and its own ladder of products from a drop-in screen to a solid cover. It is the single biggest optional add on most gutter jobs.

Soffit and fascia repair, when it’s needed — $1,500 to $2,500. Gutters hang on fascia. If the fascia behind your old gutters is soft, that gets fixed before anything new goes up, and nobody can tell you for certain until the old gutter comes down. What that work costs on its own, and the three different jobs hiding behind the words, is in what it costs to replace soffit and fascia.

And the one that surprises people: a setup charge of about $900 on small jobs. If you want twenty feet of gutter and one downspout, you pay that setup charge plus the material and the normal per-foot labor. It is not a minimum price — it’s mobilization. It costs nearly the same to load the truck, run the coil and set up for twenty feet as for two hundred.

Which is the honest answer to “why does a little job cost so much per foot?” It doesn’t cost more per foot. It costs the same per foot plus one fixed charge that a big job spreads out.

The Three Things That Decide Whether Gutters Actually Work

This is the part I’d want you to read even if you never call us, because it’s what separates a cheap quote from a bad one — and all three are checkable on a quote you already have.

One — the gutter has to hold enough. We hang 6-inch gutter only, on every house. We stopped offering 5-inch because the price difference is pennies and the 6-inch carries more water. Spectra, who make the coil we run, put it at roughly 40 to 50% more capacity — and we publish the 40, because when a manufacturer gives you a range, the bottom of it is the number you can stand behind on somebody’s house.

You will see a flat “50% more” on nearly every gutter company’s website, stated as a fact. It’s the top of a range being quoted as a specification, and I went looking for anybody who could show me where the hard number comes from. Nobody can. So if somebody quotes you the fifty, ask them for the document — not because they’re lying, but because the answer tells you whether they’ve read one.

Two — the downspouts have to empty it fast enough. Think of a gutter as a holding tank, not a pipe. In a hard rain, water comes off a roof faster than any downspout can swallow it, so the gutter’s job is to hold what’s waiting its turn.

A 2×3 downspout is 6 square inches. A 3×4 is 12 — double, and you can check it with a tape measure.

And here’s what those openings are actually for. The rule of thumb used by Texas A&M’s AgriLife Extension is one square inch of downspout for every 100 square feet of roof draining into it — which lines up with Spectra’s own numbers: a 2×3 handles about 600 square feet, a 3×4 about 1,200.

So do the sum on your own house. If you’ve got 2,400 square feet of roof draining through two 2×3 downspouts, you’ve got about half the opening you need — and no gutter, at any size, fixes that.

And a correction worth having, because this one is repeated as a rule all over the internet and it is wrong: downspout size is not tied to gutter size. You can put 3×4 downspouts on 5-inch or 6-inch gutter. They are two independent decisions.

Three — there have to be enough of them. Our rule is one downspout per 40 feet of gutter. Go count the downspouts on your quote against the length of your roofline. A hundred and sixty feet of gutter running through two downspouts is not enough, and almost nobody thinks to count.

Undersize any one of those three and you get water over the front edge in a hard rain — on a brand new gutter.

Two Things You Can See From The Ground Right Now

Look at the front face of your existing gutter. Nail heads every few feet mean spikes driven into the fascia. No visible fasteners means hidden hangers.

Spikes are the older method and Spectra is blunt about why they stopped: they always pull out of the wood over time, taking the gutter with them — and then water and debris coming off the roof go behind the gutter and straight onto the structure of the house. If you’re looking at nail heads and a gutter that’s pulling away at one end, that’s not a mystery, that’s the fastener.

And while you’re looking at the front face, the hangers behind it should be about 24 inches apart. The coil itself comes in two thicknesses — .027 and .032 — and the heavier one holds its shape better over a long run. Ask which gauge is on your quote.

And if you’re pricing leaf protection, ask one question: does any part of it go under my shingles?

A great many gutter guards are installed under the first or second course of roof shingles. Spectra — again, the manufacturer, not me — warns that this can lead to roof warranty issues, broken shingles during installation, and expensive problems later when the roof needs work. That is a question about your roof, not your gutters, and it’s worth asking before you sign anything.

What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Pace your roofline and multiply by eight. You’ll know roughly what you’re dealing with before anybody comes out.
  • Ask whether removal of the old gutters is in the number. Sometimes it isn’t.
  • Count the downspouts against your roofline length. Our rule is one per forty feet.
  • Check the downspout size with a tape. 2×3 or 3×4 — it’s double the opening.
  • Do the roof-area sum. One square inch of downspout per hundred square feet of roof draining into it.
  • If it’s a small job, expect a setup charge and ask what it is rather than assuming you’re being gouged.
  • Ask whether anything goes under your shingles. On every quote, ours included.
  • If somebody tells you 6-inch holds 50% more, ask where the number came from. The manufacturer gives a range and we publish the bottom of it. The right answer is a document, not a website.

Where We Work, And Who Sent You

We are the Home Depot service provider for gutters across all of Georgia except the Augusta area, all of Alabama, Tennessee from roughly Chattanooga across to Knoxville, and coastal and Lowcountry South Carolina — the Charleston area, south through Beaufort, Okatie, Ridgeland and Hilton Head, and inland as far as Santee.

So if Home Depot sent you our way, that’s who we are — the installer assigned to your project. We also sell gutters direct under our own name, out of Hampton and Forsyth, Georgia.

One thing about the numbers above, and it matters. Those eighty jobs are spread across four states, and the band is where they actually landed — but pricing is not the same everywhere. Material, labor and haul-off all move by market. If your house is outside the areas listed here, treat every figure on this page as a reference point and not a quote — the per-foot numbers are the part most likely to be different where you are. Ask for a number on your own house before you plan around anything written here.

Sources

The prices on this page are ours, pulled from eighty approved customer orders across Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee and South Carolina in 2026. The 6-inch-only decision, the setup charge, the one-downspout-per-40-feet rule and the free gutter assessment are ours too.

Related: Why is my gutter overflowing? · What’s the best gutter system you can put on a Georgia house?

Want A Straight Range For Your House?

Call and ask — we’ll tell you on the phone. We run a free gutter assessment: what size you need, how many downspouts, and whether the fascia behind your existing gutters is sound.

Scroll to Top