Engineered Wood Siding or Fiber Cement? What a 50-Year Prorated Warranty Really Pays

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia

If you’ve got one bid for engineered wood siding and another for fiber cement, you’re probably wondering whether the cheaper-to-install one is just as good, and whether you’re about to get talked into the expensive one by somebody who sells it. Fair question. So let me tell you up front: we install James Hardie, I get paid when you pick it, and I still think you should read the numbers below before you sign either bid.

Who’s Telling You This, And What’s His Conflict?

We install James Hardie fiber cement. That’s what we hang, and I make money when you choose it. You should know that before you read another word.

I’ve also never installed a board of LP SmartSide, the engineered wood siding most people around here are being quoted. I’ve torn off a lot of old LP and hardboard, but that’s not the same product, and I’m not going to pretend it is. Everything below is either what I’ve seen firsthand or what each manufacturer publishes about its own product, and I’ll tell you which is which.

What Is Engineered Wood Siding?

Engineered wood siding is wood strands or fibers, bonded with resins and waxes and pressed into boards. LP SmartSide is the brand you’ll see most. It’s treated to resist moisture and insects, and it’s not the same product as the old LP and Masonite that crumbles off Georgia houses. (If you’re not sure which one is on your house now, here’s how to tell LP, GP and Masonite apart.)

Fiber cement is cement, sand and cellulose fiber. James Hardie is the brand we install.

What Does Engineered Wood Actually Do Better?

I’m going to give engineered wood its due, because a comparison that only praises one side isn’t worth reading.

  • It’s lighter and cheaper to hang. Easier for a crew to carry and cut, and it goes up faster. That’s real labor savings.
  • The warranty is longer on paper. LP SmartSide carries a 50-year limited warranty with five years of 100% labor and material coverage. James Hardie’s is 30 years. More on that below, because “longer” isn’t the whole story.
  • LP says it handles hail better. LP publishes impact testing done at Texas Tech where its lap siding resisted hail damage better than comparable fiber cement and vinyl. That’s LP’s test, not mine, the same way the water test below is James Hardie’s.

Here’s the catch on cost, from what I see: engineered wood is cheaper to install, but the material itself costs more. So the total doesn’t land where most people expect.

What Happens When Engineered Wood Siding Gets Wet?

This is the whole argument for me, and it’s less about what fiber cement does than what it doesn’t do.

James Hardie ran a time-lapse test: cedar, Hardie® fiber cement and engineered wood, sitting in water for seven days. The engineered wood swells, dramatically. The fiber cement doesn’t. You can watch it on James Hardie’s own site. Remember, that’s the manufacturer’s test of its own product, so weigh it that way. But it matches what I see.

Now, I’m not going to tell you fiber cement never takes on water. It does. If a pallet of fiber cement sits out uncovered and gets saturated, it will swell. The difference is what happens next: when fiber cement dries out, it shrinks back down. Engineered wood doesn’t. It just gets worse.

And on the wall, it’s a different story anyway. Rain sheds down the face of installed siding. It doesn’t sit there and soak in. The danger is the job site, not the wall.

What Should You Check Before Anybody Hangs Your Siding?

Go look at the siding when it’s delivered to your driveway. Is it wrapped in plastic or covered?

Here’s why. Wet fiber cement isn’t ruined, but it has to dry before it goes up. If it doesn’t, one of two things happens: the job sits and waits, or the crew hangs it wet and you have a problem when it dries and shrinks on your wall.

Most contractors don’t make this a priority, so most suppliers don’t either. I’ve ordered from a lot of suppliers over the years, and only one, maybe two, consistently send the material out wrapped in plastic. If yours shows up bare and it’s going to rain, ask your contractor how they plan to cover it.

This is one thing I wish James Hardie would enforce: make plastic-wrapped delivery the standard for every supplier, every load. It would save homeowners a lot of trouble.

What Does A 50-Year Prorated Warranty Actually Pay?

This is where people get sold. “LP gives me 50 years and Hardie only gives me 30.” But you’ve got to read the word that comes before “warranty.”

LP SmartSide’s engineered wood siding warranty is prorated. After the first five years, LP’s own warranty document reduces what it pays by 2.22% for every year the siding has been up, down to zero at the end of year 50. LP also caps the total at two times what the product originally cost.

James Hardie’s 30-year warranty is non-prorated. Check this against any other fiber cement product on the market as well.

Here’s what LP’s published schedule works out to:

Year a problem shows upLP SmartSide pays (prorated)James Hardie (non-prorated)
1–5100%, labor and materialNot prorated
10About 89%Not prorated
20About 67%Not prorated
30About 44%Not prorated
40About 22%Warranty has ended
50$0—

The math: starting in year six, take off 2.22% per year. At year 30, that’s 25 years × 2.22% = 55.5% off, so LP pays roughly 44% of what it would have paid in year one. Read LP’s warranty yourself and check me.

So in my opinion, 30 years non-prorated is better than 50 years prorated, or even 100 years prorated. Why chance it?

One honest caution, so you don’t take my word for the other side either: “non-prorated” doesn’t automatically mean every cost is covered for 30 years. Read what each warranty actually pays for, labor included, before you sign anything.

Is There A House Where I’d Recommend Engineered Wood Over Fiber Cement?

No.

I gave you what engineered wood does well, and I meant it. But in my opinion the good doesn’t outweigh the risk. Lighter and cheaper to hang helps the installer. A siding that gets worse every time it soaks, backed by a warranty that’s worth less every year, doesn’t help you.

If you’re still weighing your options, here’s how every siding we see in Georgia stacks up. And if you want a number for your house before you call anybody, our siding cost calculator gives you an installed range in a few minutes.

What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Read the word “prorated.” Ask any contractor what their warranty pays in year 20, not how many years it runs.
  • Get the product in writing. Your proposal should spell out the exact product, for us that’s “primed James Hardie fiber cement with a 30-year non-prorated warranty,” not just “siding.”
  • Check the delivery. Siding sitting uncovered in the rain is a question for your contractor before it goes on the wall.
  • Don’t let a lighter install cost decide it. The material cost and the warranty matter more over the life of the house.
  • Watch the water test and decide for yourself.

Thinking about siding?

If you’ve got an engineered wood bid in hand and want a straight comparison, give us a call. We’ll walk through it line by line, even if you end up hiring somebody else.

Live in or around Atlanta? Start with our siding contractor page for Atlanta, which lays out real Metro Atlanta prices.

Scroll to Top