Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia
No. And the risk most homeowners don’t see coming isn’t picking between fiber cement siding brands — it’s being told you’re getting James Hardie and receiving a different James Hardie product that doesn’t carry the 30-year non-prorated limited, transferrable substrate warranty you thought you bought.
You can protect yourself before a single board shows up, if you know what to ask for. Here’s how.
What’s My Conflict Of Interest?
I’m an Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE. My agreement means I am not permitted to install anything but primed Hardie® siding or ColorPlus. So when I recommend Hardie, understand that I’m also describing the only product I’m allowed to sell you.
Read the rest with that in mind. I’d rather hand you that than have you find it out later.
Are You Actually Getting The Hardie® Product You Were Sold?
This is the part worth your attention.
James Hardie also makes a new-construction product line, sold as CemPlank. It’s genuinely made by James Hardie. It does not carry the same warranty as the primed Hardie® Plank most homeowners think they’re buying.
In my experience it shows up in the driveway grey, not primed yellow. That’s a useful thing to notice — but don’t rely on color to protect you, because a finish can change. Make the proposal name the exact product and the exact warranty term, and then you don’t have to identify anything by eye.
Here’s why it happens. That product costs a contractor less. Is your contractor passing that saving on to you, and explaining the warranty difference? I don’t know. I’d say the chances are slim.
And this is why I’m specific every single time I say “primed Hardie® siding.” People use “Hardie” and “HardiePlank” the way they use Kleenex — as a generic word for fiber cement. If a proposal doesn’t spell out the exact Hardie® product with a 30-year non-prorated substrate warranty, you don’t actually know what’s coming.
For what it’s worth, my agreement rules out CemPlank, which settles it for us. Other contractors might use it to save themselves or you a few dollars. That’s a hard line in the sand at our company.
What Does The Difference Actually Cost You?
Less than you’d think, and that’s the problem.
A board swap like this is worth a few thousand dollars on a typical job — real money, and completely invisible on a one-page estimate. The point isn’t that your contractor saved something. It’s that you may be the one who paid for a different warranty without being told.
The gap between fiber cement siding brands, meanwhile, is usually small. Which is worth knowing: if somebody’s meaningfully cheaper than a Hardie ALLIANCE contractor, the brand of fiber cement usually isn’t where the money went. Here’s where it usually goes.
Are Other Fiber Cement Siding Brands As Good?
Let me separate what I’ve seen from what I can prove, because you deserve to know which is which.
I have personally pulled failing boards off houses that were an earlier generation of a competing fiber cement product. I believe the problem carried forward. But here’s the limit of what I actually know: I don’t install it, I haven’t tracked whether their manufacturing changed, and I can’t point you to a current case. That’s my read from what I’ve seen with my own hands — not a finding, and not something you should take as established fact.
And I’ll go further, because it’s the honest thing to say: those failures almost certainly had installation factors in them too. I’ve told you throughout that a badly installed wall fails regardless of what’s on it. I’m not going to abandon that reasoning the moment it’s inconvenient for a competitor.
The practical comparison for a homeowner re-siding a house around here has also narrowed considerably in the last couple of years.
Which brings me to what actually bothers me, and it isn’t the board.
Who Trains The Installers?
If installation is what determines whether your wall lasts thirty years — and after eighteen years of tearing off other people’s work, I’m convinced it is — then the question worth asking about a manufacturer isn’t just what the board is made of. It’s what are they doing to make sure the people installing it get it right?
Let me tell you why I think about it that way, because it’s not flattering to me.
We were hanging fiber cement before those eighteen years started. All new construction work, and as far as we knew we were doing it right. We weren’t. We didn’t know what we didn’t know — and it stayed that way until we met a James Hardie rep who sat down with us and pointed out what we were doing wrong. That conversation is the reason I have a business that still stands behind walls from 2008. Nobody else was having it with us.
James Hardie is aggressive about this. There’s an install manual a quarter to a half inch thick. There’s contractor training. There are quick reference guides. There’s a contractor program with standards attached, and it’s specific enough that it dictates what I’m allowed to hang. They have clearly decided that a failed wall hurts them even when the failure was somebody else’s nail gun.
I’m not aware of anything equivalent from the other manufacturers. And I want to be careful with that sentence: that’s a statement about what I’ve encountered in eighteen years in this market, not proof that such programs don’t exist. I haven’t gone looking through every manufacturer’s contractor resources. They may have them.
But I can tell you what shows up in the field. And what shows up is that the manufacturer who invested hardest in training installers is the one whose product I find holding up.
That’s the reason I install what I install. Not because I think everybody else’s board is garbage — because one company is visibly working on the part that actually breaks. And I’ll say plainly: I won’t install the other brands. I also contractually can’t. Make of that what you will.
Did James Hardie Invent Fiber Cement?
People in my trade — including me, until somebody checked me on it — will tell you James Hardie invented fiber cement. They didn’t. Fiber cement is much older than they are. What Hardie developed was the modern asbestos-free version that every manufacturer now makes a form of.
That’s a narrower claim and a more impressive one. Paired with the 30-year substrate warranty on the primed product, it’s why Hardie is what I install. Done right, I know you’re getting at least thirty years. Realistically I think longer — but thirty is what I can actually promise, so thirty is what I’ll say.
What Should Your Proposal Say?
This is the actionable part. Take it to every bid you get.
And know what isn’t protecting you here. Georgia treats siding as a traditional specialty trade, exempt from the residential and general contractor licence — so there’s no state licence behind the words “siding contractor.” The building code and local permitting still apply, but nobody is checking which product landed on your wall. Your proposal is the only place that gets settled.
Your estimate should name, in writing:
- The exact product — “primed Hardie® Plank” or “Hardie® Plank with ColorPlus,” not “Hardie,” not “HardiePlank,” not “fiber cement”
- The warranty term — the 30-year non-prorated substrate warranty, spelled out
- The specific profile — lap, board and batten, shake, and the exposure
- Whether trim is Hardie® Trim or something else
If a contractor won’t put the product name and warranty term in writing, ask why. There’s no good reason not to.
What I’d Tell You If You Called Me
- Get the product name in writing before delivery day. Grey boards in the driveway are a reason to ask questions.
- Make the proposal name the product. “Fiber cement” is not a product name.
- Ask which warranty you’re getting — prorated or non-prorated, and for how long.
- A small price gap usually isn’t the brand. If somebody’s thousands cheaper, look at scope, not siding.
- Ask any contractor what they’re contractually allowed to install. It’s a more revealing question than it sounds.
Want Somebody To Read Your Proposal With You?
If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta and you’ve got a bid in hand that you can’t decode, send it over or get on the phone with me. I’ll tell you what it actually says — including if it’s a good deal and you should take it.
We do this often enough that we gave it a name: it’s our free Risk Report. We read through what you’ve been quoted and tell you plainly what’s included, what isn’t, and what risk you’d be taking on. If the other bid is solid and it’s the better offer, we’ll say so. No charge either way.
Live in or around Atlanta? Start with our siding contractor page for Atlanta, which lays out real Metro Atlanta prices.
Keep reading: Is James Hardie worth it? An honest review · The full siding cost breakdown · Who I’d put on your list of contractors
Sources: Hardie® Plank lap siding, product and warranty terms · James Hardie installation instructions and technical documents · Georgia Secretary of State, traditional specialty contractors policy statements · Georgia DCA, state minimum standard codes. Observations about competing products are All American Renovations’ own, from our own tear-offs. We do not install them and make no claim about their current manufacturing. Confirm any product’s warranty terms against the manufacturer’s own current documents before you sign anything.

Thomas Williams is co-founder of All American Renovations, which he and his brother Pete started as a gutter business in 2001 and have run in Henry County, Georgia, for 25 years. He has installed James Hardie siding since 2007 and writes the company’s Learning Center. All American Renovations is an Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE, a CertainTeed ShingleMaster and an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm. Read Thomas’s full profile or connect with Thomas on LinkedIn.
