Is It Hardie Board or Hardboard Siding? What’s Actually Falling Apart on Your House

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia

If your “Hardie board” is swelling, crumbling or falling off the wall, there’s a good chance it isn’t Hardie board at all. Most of the time it’s hardboard siding — LP, GP or Masonite. The two names sound almost exactly alike, so nobody should feel silly mixing them up. And when it really is fiber cement coming apart, it’s almost always the install.

Why Do People Call Hardboard Siding “Hardie Board”?

Say them out loud. Hardboard. Hardie board. Plenty of people spell it “Hardy board,” and that’s how most of them type it into Google.

Here’s the difference in one line each:

  • Hardie board is what most people call James Hardie fiber cement siding. People use “Hardie” the way they use Kleenex — for any fiber cement, whoever made it.
  • Hardboard is a different product family altogether. On Georgia houses that’s usually LP, Georgia Pacific (GP) or Masonite. If you want to know which one you’ve got, here’s how to tell LP, GP and Masonite apart.

I get the call all the time. “We’ve got Hardie board and it’s falling apart.” And I know what they mean.

For years I didn’t correct anybody on the phone. I didn’t want to be rude and act like I knew more than they did. “You haven’t even seen the house” is a fair thing for a homeowner to say back to me, and they’d be right — I haven’t.

So this page is the correction I never made on the phone. Not to tell you you’re wrong. Just so you know what you’re actually looking at before anybody quotes you anything.


What Does Failing Hardboard Siding Look Like?

Is it always LP, GP or Masonite when somebody tells me their Hardie board is falling apart? No. But most of the time it is.

Hardboard fails in a few ways I see over and over:

  • Swelling around the nails. The board puffs up around each nail head.
  • Crumbling at the bottom of the board. The bottom edge goes soft and breaks away.
  • Falling off the wall entirely. Boards that just let go.

If that’s what your wall is doing, this is why Masonite crumbles and what we usually find behind it.


Does Fiber Cement Siding Rot?

No. Fiber cement doesn’t rot. That’s the whole difference, and it’s why it fails differently.

IT DELAMINATES — IT COMES APART IN LAYERS.

Water gets into the bottom of the board through wicking. It starts to deteriorate the board, and eventually the water just starts washing it away, a layer at a time.

I explain it to customers like a river or a creek bed. Water washes sediment away, a little at a time, and the creek gets bigger every year. Same idea on your wall. Water is mean. Give it a place to sit and it will keep taking a little more.


Where Does Fiber Cement Come Apart First?

Almost always where water gets a second chance at the board:

  • Around the chimney
  • Where the gutters run into the siding
  • Where the siding touches the roof
  • Where it touches concrete, the ground or a deck

Every one of those is a spot where water either gets thrown at the wall or gets to sit against the bottom of a board. The required gaps at the ground and at hard surfaces are in seven things you can see from your driveway that say your siding was installed wrong.


How Can You Tell Which One Is On Your Wall?

Here’s the check, and you can do it today without a ladder.

Walk the house and look at the boards at the spots in the list above — the chimney, the gutter ends, the roof lines, and anywhere the siding meets concrete, dirt or a deck. Then look at how the damage looks:

  • Swollen and puffy around the nail heads, soft or crumbling along the bottom edge, or boards that have come off the wall? That’s the hardboard pattern. It’s very likely LP, GP or Masonite, whatever it’s been called.
  • No swelling — the board is coming apart in layers where water keeps reaching it? That’s fiber cement delaminating. And it’s telling you exactly where the water is getting in.

Take a few photos of what you find. That’s more useful to any contractor you call than the name of the product. And if you want the full rundown of what else might be on your wall, here are the types of siding we find on Georgia houses.


If It Really Is James Hardie, Why Is It Falling Apart?

This is the part that’s uncomfortable, and I’m going to say it anyway.

It’s an unfortunate situation. But I’ve never seen a correct install where true James Hardie fiber cement did this. It’s all in the install that makes the difference.

That means if your wall really is James Hardie and it’s coming apart, somebody installed it wrong. Maybe the board sat too close to the ground or the concrete. Maybe a gutter dumps water straight onto it. Maybe there was no flashing at the chimney or the roof line. The product isn’t the story — the install is.

And I can’t tell you which one it is from the phone. That cuts both ways: you can’t be sure it’s hardboard from the name, and I can’t be sure it’s an install problem until I’ve seen the house.

It’s why we follow the James Hardie best practices to a T and stand behind our install for 30 years. If I’m telling you the install is what makes the difference, I’d better be willing to put my name on mine.

If you’re weighing whether fiber cement is worth it after seeing a wall like this, here’s my honest James Hardie review, conflict of interest and all.


What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Don’t worry about the name. Call it Hardie, Hardy or hardboard — just tell us what the wall is doing.
  • Look at the trouble spots first: chimney, gutter ends, roof lines, and anywhere the siding meets the ground, concrete or a deck.
  • Swollen around the nails or crumbling at the bottom usually means LP, GP or Masonite.
  • Coming apart in layers usually means fiber cement with water getting to it — find where the water comes from before you replace anything.
  • If it really is James Hardie and it’s failing, ask the next contractor how they’ll handle those exact spots. That’s where the last one went wrong.

Not Sure What’s On Your House?

If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta, send us a few photos or let us walk it with you. We’ll tell you what’s actually on your wall, what’s causing the damage, and a straight number to fix it — even if the honest answer is that it’s a smaller job than you were braced for.

Want a ballpark first? Our siding cost calculator gives you an installed fiber cement range in a few minutes.

If your house is in Metro Atlanta, our Atlanta siding contractor page has real prices from our Metro Atlanta jobs.

Scroll to Top