Seven Things You Can See From Your Driveway That Say Your Siding Was Installed Wrong

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia


Go stand in your driveway and look at your wall. Find the vertical line where the seams stack up on top of each other, one above the next, roof to ground. That’s the first one, it’s the worst one, and you don’t need a ladder, a tape measure or a contractor to find it.

Here are six more signs of a bad siding job.

I’m going to be straight about why I’m writing this. I want you to be able to look at a wall — yours, or the one a contractor just quoted you — and know something about it without taking anybody’s word for it. Including mine.

None of this requires a tool. One of the seven requires you to walk up and stand next to the wall, and I’ll tell you when we get there.

1. Do The Seams Line Up In A Vertical Row?

This is the one I’d check first.

Siding comes in planks, so there are seams — places where one board ends and the next begins. That’s normal. What is not normal is those seams landing in the same spot course after course after course, so they form a line running down your wall.

They’re supposed to be spread out. Staggered, so that no single line on your house becomes a continuous path from the top to the bottom.

When they’re stacked, you’ve got that path. Every seam feeds the one under it, and whatever gets behind the wall at the top has a straight shot down.

Here’s how it happens, and it tells you something about who did the work. An installer runs a full board off the corner, cuts it at the same stud, starts the next course at the same place, and repeats. It’s fast. It’s the fastest possible way to do it wrong, and it means nobody was thinking about water — they were thinking about getting off the wall.

Stand back far enough to see the whole elevation. Gable ends are where it shows up most, because they’re the biggest uninterrupted walls on the house.

2. Are The Corners At Those Seams Broken Off?

Once you’ve found the seams, look closely at them. Look at the corners of the boards where they meet.

On a lot of bad installs, those corners are chipped, cracked or gone.

That is not a shipping problem and it isn’t the product being fragile. Here’s what actually happened.

Somebody drove a full-headed siding nail through the corner of the board to hold the joint tight. Which works — for about one season.

Fiber cement moves. It expands and contracts with heat and moisture, and it has to be fastened in a way that lets it. A nail with a head driven through the corner doesn’t let it. So the board did the only thing left: it moved anyway, and the corner is what gave.

Now you’ve got a hole at the seam instead of a joint. And the thing that hides it is caulk, which will be the next thing to fail.

One seam with a broken corner is a bad board. A column of them down the wall is a method.

And on a newer house, look for the opposite

Plenty of installers have figured out that a full-headed nail in the corner breaks the board. So they stopped doing that, and started pinning every joint instead — a small fastener at each seam to hold the ends down.

If you’re looking at a wall where every single joint has a little fastener at it, that’s worth understanding, because it usually isn’t a detail. It’s a symptom.

Boards that are nailed properly — into the studs, at the right height — don’t need their ends pinned to stay put. A pinned corner here and there is an ordinary finishing detail, and the manufacturer allows it for appearance. What you are looking for is every joint. When somebody has to pin every joint on a wall, it’s generally because the nails in that wall aren’t in studs, and the ends are moving. The pins are holding down a problem rather than fixing it.

So: broken corners on the older houses, a pin at every seam on the newer ones. Different decade, same root cause.

3. Is The Siding Touching The Dirt? Or The Driveway?

Walk the perimeter and look at the bottom.

Siding is supposed to stop short of things. Six inches of clearance where it could contact soil. One inch off a hard surface — a patio, a driveway, a sidewalk, a deck, a roof.

Those aren’t preferences. They’re in the manufacturer’s written instructions, and installing without them is one of the ways a warranty stops meaning anything.

I’ve had customers unhappy with me about that one-inch gap, because it looks like a mistake if you don’t know what it’s for. It isn’t. It’s the difference between a wall that dries out and a wall that wicks.

You don’t need a tape measure for the obvious cases. If the boards are sitting in mulch, or run down flush to the concrete, you can see it from ten feet away.

4. Does The Trim Sit Flush With Your Windows, Or Set Back From Them?

This one tells you whether somebody put new siding over the old siding instead of tearing it off.

Look at a window. On a normal wall, the siding and its trim sit back from the face of the window. If the siding or the J-channel is sitting flush with the window trim — or standing proud of it — the wall got thicker, and it got thicker because there’s another layer of siding under there.

Here’s the second half of the same test, and it’s my favorite. Go find an outdoor spigot. A hose bib is mounted to the wall with a plate, and the spout should stand well clear of it. If you’ve only got an inch and a half or two inches of spout sticking out where there ought to be more, the wall grew.

On 1950s-to-1980s houses now wearing vinyl, I’d say nine out of ten have two or more layers on them. More on why that matters in Can You Install New Siding Over Old Siding?

5. Can You See Nail Heads Along The Bottom Of The Boards?

This is the one where you have to leave the driveway. Walk up to the wall and look along the lap — the bottom edge of each board, where it overlaps the one below.

You should not see nail heads there.

Fiber cement is meant to be blind nailed: the fastener goes in the top of the board, roughly three-quarters of an inch to an inch down, and the next course covers it. Nothing shows. If you’re looking at heads sitting in the lap, or heads driven straight through the face of the board and puttied over, somebody shot them low, or shot them hard, or both.

And the reason this matters more than it looks: the holding power of a siding nail is in its head. Drive it too hard and the head punches through the board. The nail is still in the stud. It just isn’t holding anything.

I’ve written a whole post about this one because it’s the single thing I’ve fought with installers about since 2008, when I first read Hardie’s best practices front to back, and it’s almost always the same root cause — nobody turned the compressor down.

6. Are Your Gutters Hung On Nails?

Different trade, same principle: look at the front face of the gutter.

Nail heads every couple of feet, driven straight through the face? Those are spikes and ferrules. The old way. The spike works loose in the fascia over time and takes the gutter with it. Once that gap opens, the water coming off your roof runs behind the gutter and onto the structure of your house.

No visible fasteners at all? Hidden hangers, screwed to the fascia from inside the gutter. That’s what should be there.

Ten seconds, from the ground.

7. Does Your Gutter Guard Disappear Under The Shingles?

If you have leaf protection, stand back and look at where the roof edge meets the gutter.

Does the guard stop at the gutter, or does the back edge slide up under the first course of shingles?

Plenty of them install that way, because it’s a quick way to make a rigid panel sit right. Here’s what we’ve seen come of it: shingles broken during the guard installation, and a bill later when the roof needs work and every cover has to come off and go back on. And ask your roofer before you let anyone lift a shingle course — a roofing manufacturer’s warranty has conditions, and that’s a question for the company that warranties your roof, not for your gutter installer.

Found Signs Of A Bad Siding Job? Now What?

Here’s the part that costs me money to write, and I’d rather you hear it from me.

Finding these does not mean you need to do anything this month.

Whatever damage has happened has mostly already happened. Nothing is going to collapse. If water is being kept out well enough that you’re not seeing it inside, six to twelve months is a perfectly sensible timeline, and eighteen months while you save up is usually fine too.

Anybody who tells you different is probably trying to coerce you.

And here’s the thing underneath this whole page. Georgia treats siding as a traditional specialty trade, exempt from the residential and general contractor licence — so no state licence stands behind the words “siding contractor,” and nobody inspected most of the walls I’m describing. The building code and local permitting still apply, but on a re-side nobody is checking the nail line. That’s why you looking at your own wall is worth something. It’s also why it matters which siding contractors in Atlanta you compare before you sign.

The things that should actually move you sooner: staining or soft spots on interior ceilings or walls, particularly below a window and away from the roof. That’s water that already found a way in, and waiting on that one gets expensive.

And I’ll tell you the honest limit of everything on this page. These seven things are what you can see. What none of us can see is what’s behind the wall — the sheathing, the wrap, whether that stacked-joint column has been feeding water into something for ten years. Nobody knows that until boards come off. Any contractor who gives you a confident number for it while standing in your driveway is guessing, and you should treat the number that way.

What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Do the walk before you get any bids, not after. Ten minutes, no tools. You’ll ask completely different questions.
  • Take pictures of whatever you find, wide and close. It makes every conversation after that shorter.
  • Ask any contractor bidding your job how they stagger the joints and what goes behind them. If the answer is caulk, you’ve learned something. There should be flashing there.
  • Ask what fastener goes at the ends of the boards. You now know what a nail head through the corner does — and what a pin at every joint usually means.
  • If you’re getting more than one bid, ask each of them to point at something on your wall and explain it. The one who walks you to it and shows you is not the same as the one who hands you a number.
  • Don’t let anybody use what you found to rush you, including me.

Want Somebody To Walk It With You?

If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta, we’ll come look at what you found and tell you what it means — including if it means less than you think.

And if you’ve already got bids in hand, that’s what our Free Risk Report is for. We’ll read them and tell you what’s in them, what isn’t, and what risk comes with each. If somebody else’s bid is the better offer, we’ll say so.

If your house is in Metro Atlanta, our Atlanta siding contractor page has real prices from our Metro Atlanta jobs.

Keep reading: Why the nails are the whole ballgame · Can you install new siding over old siding? · What do new gutters cost? · Why we’re usually not the lowest bid

Sources: James Hardie installation instructions and technical documents · HardiePlank lap siding, warranty terms · Georgia Secretary of State, traditional specialty contractors policy statements · Georgia DCA, state minimum standard codes. Every diagnostic, mechanism and field observation on this page is All American Renovations’ own, from our own tear-offs in Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta. For anything touching your roofing warranty, ask the company that issued it.

Scroll to Top