Can You Just Repair My LP Siding? (Honest Answer, Middle Georgia)

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia


Sometimes, yes. Usually, no — and not for the reason you’d think. The problem with most LP and Georgia Pacific siding around here isn’t the product. It’s that every single house I’ve seen it on was face nailed, and that’s what turns an LP siding repair of two boards into a whole wall.

Here’s how to tell which one you are.

Why Is My LP Siding Falling Apart?

Nearly every house in Georgia built from the 1970s into the early 2000s got LP or Georgia Pacific siding. And every one I’ve opened up was face nailed — nails driven straight through the face of the board.

Every siding product moves. Vinyl, LP, fiber cement, all of it. Boards expand and contract with the seasons, and there has to be an allowance for that. A face nail doesn’t allow it. The board tries to move anyway, and something has to give.

What gives is the caulk. Around the nail heads, in the joints, everywhere. Which means those nail holes need re-caulking every year or two, and then repainting on top of it.

Nobody does that. And I don’t blame them — who wants a house that looks like polka dots and zebra stripes because of all the caulk?

So the caulk opens up. Water gets in. The board starts delaminating from the bottom edge up. Ten years of that and the paint is about the only thing holding it together.

Let me be fair to the product. Installed right and maintained right, LP is an okay product. It’s lighter than fiber cement and cheaper to hang, and those are real advantages. I still think it’s cardboard with a texture on it, but it didn’t have to fail this way. I go further into that in Is LP Siding Really That Bad?

And this isn’t only an LP problem. I see the exact same failure on badly installed Hardie® siding. Face nail instead of blind nailing into the studs and you get the same delamination, the same boards working loose. The product on your wall matters a lot less than whether whoever hung it followed the manual.

Why Does One Board Turn Into The Whole Wall?

This is the part people don’t expect.

You pull the bad board at the bottom. The next one up falls apart in your hands. Then the one above that. You’re not making a decision to replace the section — the wall makes it for you.

And if you’ve got a problem in one spot, you almost always have it in two or three more. Most of the time when you have one area, you have more areas. You just don’t realize it yet.

How Do I Tell How Bad Mine Is?

Walk your house this weekend. Follow the water.

  • Chimneys. Where fascia dies into a chimney chase without flashing, water runs down that siding every time it rains.
  • Windows and sills.
  • Decks and concrete patios. Water hits the hard surface, jumps back up, and wicks into the bottom edge of the board.

One thing worth knowing if your house is older than 1978: the paint on that siding may be lead paint, and disturbing it is federally regulated work. We are an EPA Lead-Safe Certified firm and we handle lead mitigation ourselves — but whoever you hire, you can check that they are certified before they touch a board.

Damage starts at the bottom and works its way up as the house ages and the paint fades. What you’re looking for: bottom edges crumbling, boards delaminating in layers, nails sticking out, boards that feel loose. Anything that didn’t look like that when you bought the house. Not sure whether it’s LP, GP or Masonite? Here’s how to tell.

The tell most people miss: if somebody already came out and replaced two or three boards along the bottom, look at the boards above the patch. Those are the honest ones. That wear was already in them — they just weren’t as far gone as the ones that got replaced. A patch job is usually proof the rest of the wall is on the same clock.

What Does It Cost Me To Wait A Year?

Honestly? Probably not much.

If water has already gotten in and started rotting the sheathing, maybe into a stud, one more year isn’t going to change that picture dramatically. I’d rather tell you that than scare you into a loan.

But don’t just leave it. If there’s an open spot at a chimney or a wall, tarp it, flash it, have a handyman patch it, do it yourself — whatever keeps water from running in for another year. That part matters.

Where it gets expensive is the long game. Ten or fifteen years of ignoring it and you’re into real structural damage, and on our own jobs that has run $7,000 to $15,000 on top of the siding. That is our number off our own tear-offs, not an industry figure.

One thing worth knowing: delaminated boards at the bottom usually aren’t where the serious rot is. The bad rot is higher up, where kick-out flashing got missed at a chimney, or anywhere water sits — a deck connection, a wall above a basement.

When Is LP Siding Repair Ever The Right Call?

Yes, sometimes. Tight budget, one wall, everything else genuinely fine — sometimes patching is the right move. Especially if you’re listing the house and one section is going to cause you problems on inspection.

But I’m not your guy for it. We’re not a handyman business, and we’re not equipped to come replace one or two boards. You can absolutely find someone who is, and you should.

Where we can help is a section — 200 to 500 square feet, a whole wall or a good piece of one. We’ll do that. Two things you should know going in:

It costs more per square foot than doing the house. Labor is labor. Mobilizing a crew, bringing equipment, setting a dumpster — that’s the same whether we’re doing one wall or four.

You’ll probably end up painting the whole house anyway. New siding with fresh paint next to ten-year-old siding doesn’t match, and it won’t.

Is a one-section repair common? No. And you won’t get much back on it. If you patch one wall and leave the rest LP, you’ve spent money without changing what the house is.

Compare that to doing it right: the 2025 Cost vs. Value report puts fiber-cement siding replacement at 114% of cost recouped at resale nationally, on a $21,485 average job — fourth of the 28 projects in that year’s report. Vinyl siding came in at 97%. That’s a national average and it swings year to year, so don’t treat it as a promise on your specific house.

What’s Hard About Hiring Us?

Three things, and I’d rather you hear them from me.

We’re rarely the low bid. If I’m the low bid on your siding, something’s probably wrong — we likely made a calculation mistake somewhere. If we did, we own it, because we’re the ones who gave you the number. More on that in why we’re not the lowest bid.

We’re typically booked four to six weeks out. Fall usually opens up some.

You can’t just get a number on Thursday. Our process starts with a phone call, and we’re going to ask you to shoot eight photos of your house yourself for the HOVER model. If what you want is somebody to show up and hand you a price on the spot, we’re not that company. Some people would rather have it that way, and that’s a fair preference — it just isn’t how we work.

What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Look at the boards above the patch, not the patch. That’s where the truth is.
  • If you can’t afford it this year, keep water out of it and wait. One more year rarely changes the math.
  • Ask any contractor whether they blind nail into studs. If the answer is vague, keep calling.
  • One bad area usually means three. Get the whole house looked at before you price a wall.
  • If you need two boards replaced, call a handyman, not us. We’d just be the expensive answer.

Not Sure How Bad Yours Is?

If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta and you want a straight read on your siding, I’ll get on the phone with you first — no charge, no appointment to sit through. We’ll talk through what you’re seeing and what it likely means before anybody comes out.

We’re not here to sell. We’re here to consult and educate, and I’d rather you end up with a good installation from somebody else than a bad one from us.

Wondering what a full replacement actually runs? Here’s the complete siding cost breakdown for Middle Georgia.

Sources: James Hardie installation instructions and technical documents · EPA, finding a Lead-Safe Certified firm · Zonda / JLC, Cost vs. Value 2025. Pricing, condition findings and the structural range above are All American Renovations’ own, from our own jobs in Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta.

Scroll to Top