Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia
You’re standing in your yard at six in the evening, everybody’s gone home, and something doesn’t look right.
You’re unhappy with contractor work that’s still underway, and you haven’t said anything.
I want to talk about that gap — between noticing and saying — because it’s where almost all of the real damage in this business happens, and it has nothing to do with the work itself.
Unhappy With Contractor Work? Why You Haven’t Said Anything
I’ve been doing this twenty-five years and it’s always one of three reasons.
You’re not sure it’s actually wrong. You don’t do this for a living. Maybe that gap closes up. Maybe that’s how it’s supposed to look before the trim goes on. You don’t want to be the person who made a fuss about something that was fine.
You don’t want to be the difficult customer. There’s a version of this where you complain, and the crew gets cold with you, and now you’ve got six weeks of that at your own house. That’s a completely rational thing to want to avoid.
Or you’re saving it up. You’re going to mention it at the end, when the job’s done and you’re not standing next to the man who did it.
All three of those are understandable. All three of them cost you money.
First, Though: Catching It Shouldn’t Be Your Job
Before I tell you to speak up, let me say what should be true if the speaking up never had to happen.
You hired a general contractor so that you wouldn’t have to inspect your own house. That’s most of what you’re paying for, and if the only thing standing between a bad install and a finished wall is whether the homeowner happened to notice, you didn’t buy a contractor. You bought a crew and a lot of responsibility.
So here’s what’s supposed to catch it before you do: a lead man on every job whose responsibility is the work being right. A project manager checking it against a written list — not once at the end, several times through the job. And Chris or I come and look at it while it’s happening, not after. Who’s actually going to be at my house sets out who those people are and how the checklist works.
What I say to our guys constantly is this: look at this like it was your home. If you wouldn’t be happy with it, it doesn’t pass.
I’ve had a job where a tile installation didn’t meet our standard and the customer never knew there had been a problem. Our project manager caught it, took it to the installers, and it was corrected. The homeowner didn’t have to notice. Didn’t have to call. Didn’t have to have an uncomfortable conversation.
That’s the standard. It is our job to make sure things are done right. That is not your job — that’s why you hired us.
And Here’s What It Looks Like When It’s Actually Bad
The tile is the routine version. Here’s the other kind, and I’d rather you heard it from me.
We had a crew on a siding job — people who had worked with us for years. We had gone through James Hardie’s best practices together, start to finish, to make sure everybody was on the same page, which is the first item on our own quality checklist and not a formality.
I drove out to look at the first day’s work and found they had done the opposite of what I’d shown them.
No starter strip at all. The bottom course hanging about two inches below the sill plate.
I pulled the board off the wall myself and told them to take the rest of it off and start again.
They started again. And they still didn’t follow all of James Hardie’s requirements.
So I took them off the job. Brought a different crew in, had them undo what was there, and install the whole wall properly.
And they don’t work for us any more. Years of jobs together, and that was the end of it.
I’d rather you know that than think I’m telling you a story with a tidy ending. Two chances, on a standard we’d gone through together in writing that same week — and a relationship that long ends over it. That’s what the standard being real actually costs somebody, and it isn’t always the customer.
The part that matters is what the customer paid
Nothing.
He wasn’t happy, and he was entitled not to be — his house had gone sideways twice and he’d watched both times. I was angrier about it than he was.
And then he said the thing I suspect a lot of homeowners would be thinking: he reckoned I’d find a way to change-order him for the extra material.
I looked him in the eye and told him that if he really believed that, he’d hired the wrong guy.
There was no rot on that house, so there was no change order, and there were no extra charges of any kind. The second crew, the wasted material, the lost days — that was ours.
Our price is our price. No matter what happens.
That’s the sentence we’re least flexible about. It’s why we don’t come down to match somebody else’s number, and it’s the same reason we’re usually not the lowest bid. This is the job that shows you which direction it actually points.
When our own mistake costs money, it costs us.
But The System Isn’t Perfect, And I’m Not Going To Pretend It Is
We’re people. On a four-week job with several trades, something will get past somebody.
Which is why the thing I need from you is the one thing I can’t do myself: tell me.
And here’s what I’d ask you to believe, because it’s the part that makes saying something safe rather than risky.
Three Reasons Speaking Up Costs You Nothing
One: if it’s wrong, it comes down and gets installed again. That’s not a negotiation and it isn’t a favor. It’s the only solution to a problem like that, and you just read how far we’ll take it.
Two: raising something doesn’t put you in a payment fight. If the work isn’t up to our standard, we don’t request that draw until it is — not because you complained, but because we don’t accept it from our own tradespeople. How much should a contractor ask for up front explains how the draws work. You are not going to find yourself being asked to pay for something we’ve agreed is wrong.
Three: a question is not a complaint, and nobody here treats it as one. “Can you explain why that’s done that way?” is a normal sentence. Most of the time the answer is a reason you hadn’t thought of — and you’ve lost nothing by asking. Occasionally the answer is “you’re right, that shouldn’t look like that.” Both of those outcomes are good ones.
The Arithmetic Of Staying Quiet, Which Is The Real Point Of This Page
Here’s why I’d rather have the awkward conversation in week two.
Something flagged in week two is a fix. The trade is still on site, the wall is still open, nobody’s been paid for it yet.
The same thing flagged at the final walkthrough is a rework. Now we’re bringing a crew back, possibly taking finished work off to get at it, and scheduling around whoever else we’ve committed to.
And the same thing never flagged at all is something you look at for fifteen years.
That last one is the one that actually happens, and it’s the one I’d most like to prevent. People live with things they could have had corrected for nothing, because the week they noticed it felt like the wrong week to mention it.
There is no wrong week to mention it. There’s an expensive week and a cheap week, and the cheap week is always now.
Who To Call, Practically
Call Chris, or call me. Not the crew.
That isn’t about going over anybody’s head — it’s that the lead man on your job is responsible for the work, and the project manager is responsible for the standard. Those are different jobs, and a quality question belongs with the second one.
It also means nobody on site has to decide whether something is acceptable while you’re standing there watching them decide. That’s an unfair position to put a tradesman in and it produces worse answers.
And one thing we ask in return, which I think is fair: if something isn’t right, we have to be given the opportunity to fix it. Tell us, let us put it right, and by the time the job is finished everything will be done as planned, as expected, and to our standards. That part isn’t negotiable on our end.
What I’d Tell You If You Called Me
- Say it the day you notice it. Not the week, the day. There is no version of this where waiting makes it cheaper.
- Ask a question instead of making an accusation — it’s easier for you, and it gets you a better answer. “Why is it done that way?” works on anything.
- Take a photograph. Not as evidence. Because “the thing near the corner” is hard to find again once the scaffolding has moved.
- Call the project manager, not the crew. Different job, different responsibility.
- Don’t save it up for the walkthrough. The walkthrough is for the small stuff that’s left, not for the thing you’ve been carrying since week two.
- And if you’re genuinely not sure whether something is wrong — ask anyway. Being wrong about it costs you one short conversation. Being right about it and saying nothing costs you a lot more.
And If You’re Reading This Before You’ve Hired Anybody
Ask whoever you’re considering what happens when a homeowner raises a concern mid-job. Listen for whether there’s a person and a process, or whether the answer is “just tell the guys.”
Then ask who decides whether the work is good enough to bill for. If the honest answer is that nobody checks until the customer complains, you’ve found the thing this whole page is about.
Want To Know Who’d Be At Your House And Who You’d Call?
We’ll tell you before you sign anything. We’re in Hampton, with a design center in Forsyth, and we work across Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta.
Everything on this page is our own process and our own jobs. There’s nothing cited here because there’s nothing to cite.
All American Renovations — (770) 629-0589

Thomas Williams is co-founder of All American Renovations, which he and his brother Pete started as a gutter business in 2001 and have run in Henry County, Georgia, for 25 years. He has installed James Hardie siding since 2007 and writes the company’s Learning Center. All American Renovations is an Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE, a CertainTeed ShingleMaster and an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm. Read Thomas’s full profile or connect with Thomas on LinkedIn.
