Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia
Yes — house settling cracks siding sometimes. It happens, and anybody who tells you it never does is wrong. But settling almost never shows up in your siding alone — it leaves a trail through the rest of the house. If the siding is the only thing wrong, the cause is usually how it was put on.
Here’s why I’m writing this one.
Somebody you trust has probably already told you what’s wrong. A brother, a neighbor, a friend who builds things. They walked your house, they looked at the cracks and the separated joints, and they gave you an answer — and they were trying to help you, which is more than most people do.
The hard part isn’t that they might be wrong. It’s that you have no way to tell. That’s an uncomfortable place to stand when you’re about to spend real money.
So this is how to tell.
Can Settling Really Crack Siding?
It can. A foundation that moves takes the framing with it, and the framing takes everything nailed to it — siding included. So it’s a fair thing to suspect, and I’m not going to wave it off.
But a moving foundation doesn’t pick on your siding and leave the rest of the house alone. Whatever is strong enough to crack a wall is strong enough to show up in three or four other places at the same time.
That’s what makes this easy to check.
How Do You Tell House Settling Cracks From A Bad Install?
This takes about five minutes and you don’t need a ladder.
1. The foundation itself
Walk the perimeter and look at the concrete or block below the siding. You’re looking for cracks — especially ones that run at an angle, or that are wider at one end than the other.
2. The trim around your windows
Look at whether it’s still square. Settling shifts window openings, and the trim is where it shows first — gaps that are wider at the top than the bottom, or a piece of trim that’s pulled away at one corner and tight at the other.
3. Your doors
Go open and close every exterior door, and a few interior ones. Doors that stick, that won’t latch, that swing open on their own, or that have a gap along one side and none along the other. Doors are sensitive, and they tell on a house early.
Now put it together.
Cracks in the siding and cracks in the foundation and shifted window trim and doors that won’t work right? That’s a house that’s moving. Take it seriously, and keep reading to the uncomfortable part below, because your next call probably isn’t a siding contractor.
Cracks in the siding and everything else in the house behaving normally? It’s almost certainly not settling. And at that point there’s a much more common explanation.
What Does It Look Like When It’s The Installation Instead?
This is what I find on most of the houses I get called to look at, and once you know what you’re looking at, it’s obvious.
Look at the ends of the boards — the butt joints, where one board meets the next. On a wall that was installed wrong, the corners of those board ends are broken off. Not chipped from a lawnmower. Snapped, at the joint, over and over down the wall.
Here’s the mechanism, and it’s simple.
Fiber cement moves. It expands and contracts with heat and cold and moisture, the same as everything else on your house. The installation is supposed to allow for that.
When somebody drives a full-headed siding nail through the corner of a board end, that corner can’t move any more. But the rest of the board still does. So the board pulls against a point that’s pinned, over and over, season after season — and eventually the corner just breaks off.
Once it’s broken, the joint opens up. That’s the gap you’re looking at.
One more thing to look for while you’re out there. Stand back and see whether the butt joints line up in a vertical column, running up the wall. They shouldn’t. Joints are supposed to be staggered, and a stack of them in a straight line is a sign the wall went up fast.
Why Does This Happen So Much On Newer Houses?
This is the part that surprises people, because they assume a newer house means a better install.
I see this time and time and time again on new construction. And I’m not going to pretend I don’t understand why. A builder’s siding crew is paid to get the house done and get to the next one. Their goal is speed, because speed is what they’re measured on. Nobody on that site is checking whether the nail landed in the right part of the board.
The homeowner doesn’t find out for ten or fifteen years, because that’s how long it takes for the expansion and contraction to do its work. By then the builder is gone, the crew is gone, and the house is yours.
A house built in the mid-2000s or 2010s that’s showing this now is right on schedule. That’s not bad luck. That’s the timeline.
How Worried Should I Actually Be?
Less than you probably are right now, and I’ll tell you why.
On any house built in the last couple of decades, there should be a weather barrier behind that siding — housewrap or felt, over the sheathing, underneath everything you can see. Georgia’s residential code requires a water-resistive barrier behind fiber cement and hardboard siding, and it has for a long time now. The current edition is the 2024 International Residential Code with Georgia Amendments.
On older houses, often there’s nothing back there at all. And that isn’t a story about bad contractors — the code in force when those houses went up didn’t ask for a barrier behind lap siding, and contractors build what the code asks for. If your house went up in the eighties or nineties and the siding hasn’t been replaced since, assume the siding is the only layer.
Either way, I can’t guarantee what’s on your house without opening a wall, and I won’t pretend otherwise.
This matters because siding isn’t what keeps water out of your house. It’s the first layer. The wrap behind it is the one doing the real work when something gets past.
So on a newer house, when a joint opens up, water that gets in there is landing on a barrier rather than on your framing. On an older one, it’s landing on your sheathing — which is why the timeline below matters more if your house is older.
Does it need to be fixed? Yes. Left alone long enough, this gets worse and it gets more expensive. But rot takes a long time to happen, and the difference between dealing with this today and dealing with it in six weeks is not going to change your outcome.
I’d rather you take the time to do this right than rush it because somebody scared you. That includes not rushing it because of me.
The one thing that does mean move sooner: water showing up inside — stains on ceilings, or below windows, in places that have nothing to do with your roof. That’s a different conversation and it starts now.
What If It Is Settling? Then We Won’t Do Your Siding
Not “we’d rather not.” We won’t.
New siding on a foundation that’s still moving is money spent on a symptom. Whatever cracked that wall the first time hasn’t stopped, and it will do to the new siding exactly what it did to the old siding. You’d be paying me to cover up a problem that’s still running.
So the order matters, and it isn’t negotiable: the underlying problem gets fixed first. Then the siding.
Here’s what that actually looks like if you call us and it turns out to be movement.
We’ll refer you to a structural engineer. We have one we send people to, and we’ll make the introduction — it’s case by case, because the right person depends on what’s going on with your house. You want a report before anybody quotes you anything, including us.
Then we’ll help you get the repairs handled that the report calls for. You don’t have to go run that down by yourself. That’s a real part of what we do, and it’s the reason we’d rather you call us and get told no than not call at all.
And then, once the house is stable, we’ll talk about siding.
I’d rather tell you that up front than take a deposit and find out in three years.
One more uncomfortable thing, and it cuts against me too: I can’t diagnose your house from photographs, and neither can anybody else. Photos are enough for me to tell you what I’m probably looking at, and that’s genuinely useful before you spend a day meeting contractors. They are not enough for me to promise you what’s behind the wall. Anybody who does that from their truck is guessing.
What I’d Tell You If You Called Me
- Do the three checks first. Foundation, window trim, doors. Five minutes, and it tells you which problem you actually have.
- If it’s only the siding, look at the joints. Broken corners and stacked joints mean installation, not movement.
- Don’t let anybody rush you. Not your family, not a salesman, not me. This is a six-to-twelve-month decision, not a this-week decision, unless water is getting inside.
- Whoever you call, ask what they’re trained and credentialed to install, and check it yourself rather than taking their word for it. And know what that check does and doesn’t cover. Georgia treats siding as a traditional specialty trade, exempt from the residential and general contractor licence — so there’s no state trade licence to look up. What you can check is manufacturer training, insurance, and EPA lead-safe certification if the house predates 1978. The building code and local permitting still apply regardless.
- And don’t take my word for any of this either. Get two or three opinions. If they all say the same thing, you know. If one of them is the odd one out, ask him to show you why.
Want A Second Opinion On What You’re Looking At?
If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta, send me photos and I’ll tell you honestly what I think you’re dealing with — including if I think it’s settling, in which case you need an engineer before you need me, and I’ll point you at one.
If it turns out to be the installation, we’ll walk the house, pull real measurements, and give you a line-item number you can hold up against anybody else’s.
All American Renovations — (770) 629-0589
For homes in Metro Atlanta, our Atlanta siding replacement page shows what siding jobs there actually cost.
Keep reading: Seven things you can see from your driveway that say your siding was installed wrong · Watch the nails
Sources: Georgia DCA, state minimum standard codes · James Hardie installation instructions and technical documents · Georgia Secretary of State, traditional specialty contractors policy statements · EPA, finding a Lead-Safe Certified firm. Code requirements change by edition and by material — confirm what applied when your house was built with your county’s building department. Everything else on this page is what we find on our own jobs in Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta. We are not structural engineers and this page is not a structural assessment.

Thomas Williams is co-founder of All American Renovations, which he and his brother Pete started as a gutter business in 2001 and have run in Henry County, Georgia, for 25 years. He has installed James Hardie siding since 2007 and writes the company’s Learning Center. All American Renovations is an Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE, a CertainTeed ShingleMaster and an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm. Read Thomas’s full profile or connect with Thomas on LinkedIn.
