ColorPlus or Primed and Painted? An Honest Comparison (Middle Georgia, 2026)

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia


ColorPlus vs primed and painted comes down to this: ColorPlus is James Hardie’s factory-finished Hardie® siding, and primed and painted means we hang the board and a painter finishes it on your house. On a full siding, soffit and fascia job around here, ColorPlus runs $20,000 to $30,000 more up front — and carries a 15-year limited warranty that covers paint and labor instead of a five-to-seven-year repaint cycle.

Which one is right depends almost entirely on how long you’re staying. Here’s everything I’d tell you at your kitchen table.

ColorPlus Vs Primed And Painted: What’s The Actual Difference?

ColorPlusPrimed and painted
Cost on a full siding/soffit/fascia job+$20,000–$30,000baseline
Finish warranty15-year limited warranty covering paint and laborvaries by painter — ask for it in writing
Repaint cyclenone in that window5–7 years typical, some get 10
Color choicesa curated factory palette — check what’s stocked for your ZIPany color made
How it fadesevenlyunevenly, starting on the texture ridges
Repairing a board latermatches well, may need area blendingpatch shows sooner, repaint the area
Time to finish the jobhalf a day to a day of caulkadds 3–5 working days of paint, plus any wait on a painter

Real numbers from a real job: early 2025, three-bed two-bath ranch. Siding, soffit, fascia and gutters, primed and painted — $25,000 to $30,000. That same house in ColorPlus was right around $50,000. Today, late 2026, that job is closer to $55,000 to $60,000.

Every price on this page is ours, off our own jobs in Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta, as of late 2026. Nobody publishes an index for this. If you want to see why the same house can swing that far, I walk through it in why siding costs $15,000 on one house and $60,000 on another.

You’re either paying for it now, or you’re paying for it later.

Why Does ColorPlus Actually Hold Color Longer?

Everybody in my business sells ColorPlus on the fifteen-year warranty. That’s not the real reason. Here’s the real reason, and once you see it you can’t unsee it.

Blow up a side view of a siding board. That woodgrain texture isn’t flat — it’s ridges and valleys.

ColorPlus is finished in a factory with robot eyes watching it. The paint goes on at the same thickness across the whole board: same on the high points as the low points, same left to right, same top to bottom.

Field paint is a human being with a sprayer, back-rolling, maybe brushing. That person is doing good work — but it is genuinely impossible to lay down identical thickness across every ridge and valley on a wall of siding. It isn’t carelessness. It’s just what happens when paint meets texture.

You can’t see the difference the day it’s done. The wall looks perfect.

But that’s what fading actually is. When you start seeing a board look faded, what you’re seeing is the thin paint on the ridges giving out first, while the valleys still hold color. That’s why field-painted siding fades in a patchy, blotchy way.

ColorPlus has the same thickness everywhere, so when it does fade, it fades evenly. Which is why it still looks like a color instead of looking worn.

I’ve got houses we sided in 2008, 2012, 2013 and 2015. Drive by them today — still as colonial red as the day we installed them.

Can You Actually Get The Color You Want?

This is the question that decides it for more people than price does.

ColorPlus comes as a curated factory palette rather than unlimited color, and that palette has been narrower at some points than at others. For a few years Hardie cut it way back, and it has since opened up again. There is also a custom-color line at a meaningfully higher price. What is actually stocked, in which profile, changes — so the only answer worth having is the one for your ZIP code on the day you buy. Check the current product range and we will confirm what is available for your house before you choose.

Darker schemes are what most of our customers are choosing right now.

On the custom-color line, I’ll be straight with you: I’m not as big a fan of that finish as I am of the standard ColorPlus palette. It’s a different process — custom color versus the rolled-on, baked-on finish the standard palette gets. I’m not going to tell you not to buy it. I’ll give you the facts and let you decide.

And if you have your heart set on one specific color that isn’t in the lineup? Go primed and painted. That’s my honest recommendation. I’ve had customers do exactly that, and it was the right call for them.

Most people, though, find something they love in the standard colors.

What Happens If A Board Gets Damaged In Year Six?

Fair question, and the answer is better than people expect.

Somebody cleaning your gutters puts a ladder through a board. A trailer clips a corner. We come replace those boards with the same ColorPlus product, and it matches.

Hail is rarely the issue — it takes seriously big, hard hail to damage fiber cement, and if you get that, you’ve got a widespread insurance claim, not a two-board repair.

The real question is whether a brand-new board matches six-year-old siding. Honest answer: I don’t know for certain. We’ve been installing ColorPlus since 2008 and it hasn’t come up. Six years of Georgia sun is six years of UV, so there’s probably some fade — but because it fades evenly, the gap should be small. If it showed, we’d blend the surrounding area so it doesn’t read as a patch.

With primed and painted, there’s no uncertainty. That fade is uneven, so a new board next to six-year-old boards will show. You’re repainting that whole section, not swapping two boards.

Why Does The Expensive One Finish Sooner?

Everybody argues ColorPlus on warranty and fade. Here’s a reason I’ve never heard anybody in this trade give, and it’s got nothing to do with either.

ColorPlus gets your job done faster.

When we hang primed siding, we’re not finished when the siding is up. A painter still has to come. That’s three to five working days of painting — weather depending, and in Georgia that’s a real caveat.

And it isn’t only those days. It’s a separate trade with its own schedule. Sometimes the siding is complete and the painter is backed up and can’t start for a week. That week is nobody’s fault and it’s not on any estimate, but it’s a week where your house sits finished-but-not-finished and nothing is happening.

ColorPlus arrives on the truck already finished. There’s still about half a day to a day of caulk at the end — I’m not going to tell you it’s zero. But that’s a half day against three to five days plus somebody else’s schedule.

So if you’re working around a listing date, a move-in, a wedding, a baby — anything with a real deadline on it — the more expensive option is also the shorter one. That’s worth knowing before you choose, and I’d rather you hear it from me than work it out afterward.

So Which One Should You Buy?

Ask yourself one question: how long are you going to be in this house?

Flipping in a year or two. Skip ColorPlus. You want a good installation so an inspector or appraiser doesn’t ding you for failing siding. That’s it.

Five to ten years. This is the iffy zone. At five years you probably don’t recoup it on paint savings alone. What you do get is a selling point at listing — this went on five years ago and the finish is warrantied another ten.

Staying put. ColorPlus earns its money. Run the math: say paint costs $10,000 today, $12,000 to $15,000 in five to seven years, $14,000 to $17,000 five to seven years after that. Add picking colors again, and vetting another contractor again, and wondering again whether they’ll do what they said. You’ve often spent more than the upfront difference.

What’s on my house? Primed and painted. We built in 2020, mid-COVID, and I wanted a 5¼ smooth lap with a 4-inch reveal plus some board and batten. The ColorPlus upgrade on that profile didn’t pencil at the time.

If I had it to do over again, I’d put ColorPlus on my house. Next time, I probably will.

What Are People Around Here Actually Choosing?

I’ll show you my own numbers, because they tell the story better than I can.

Before Hardie cut the palette back, we were putting roughly 7 out of every 10 jobs in ColorPlus.

After the cut, over about five years, we sold maybe two or three ColorPlus jobs total. Customers didn’t like the color availability, and I wasn’t confident enough in the custom finish to push it.

Since the palette came back: 6 of the last 20 jobs. A few of the other fourteen seriously considered it, and landed on primed and painted because of color or budget.

My job is not to sell you one product or the other. Maybe James Hardie doesn’t want to hear that. But my responsibility is to educate and consult, and help you land on what’s the best decision for you at this point in your life.

What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Decide by how long you’re staying, not by the sticker price.
  • If you’re on a deadline, ask how long each option takes. ColorPlus costs more and finishes sooner. Almost nobody will tell you that.
  • Look at the current colors before you assume they won’t work. The palette is a lot better than it was a couple of years ago.
  • If you want one specific color that isn’t offered, go primed and painted. Don’t force it.
  • Ask any contractor to explain why ColorPlus lasts. If they only say “fifteen-year warranty,” they don’t know.
  • Either way, the install matters more than the finish. Beautiful paint on a badly nailed wall is still a badly nailed wall. Here’s what to watch for.

Want To See Your House In A Few Of These Colors?

If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta, we’ll pull HOVER measurements and show you your actual home in different colors and profiles before you spend a dollar. Then you can decide with your eyes instead of a brochure.

No pressure, and no obligation to go further than a phone call.

If your house is in Metro Atlanta, our Atlanta siding contractor page has real prices from our Metro Atlanta jobs.

Want the full numbers first? Here’s the complete siding cost breakdown for Middle Georgia, and what a full exterior renovation costs.

Sources: James Hardie, ColorPlus lifetime value and finish warranty · Hardie® Plank lap siding product page · James Hardie installation instructions and technical documents. All pricing, sales figures and installation observations are All American Renovations’ own. Color and profile availability changes — confirm what is stocked for your ZIP code before you decide.

Scroll to Top