Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia
Most Georgia houses wear one of a handful of types of siding: hardboard (Masonite, LP, GP), vinyl, cedar, fiber cement, T1-11, stucco or EIFS, and once in a while aluminum or metal panels. You can tell which one you have from your driveway in about five minutes. The harder part is knowing whether what you found is fine or a problem — and almost nobody who sells siding has a reason to tell you it’s fine.
So this post does both. First, how to identify what’s on your house. Then, type by type, whether you can live with it for years or should start setting money aside. I’ll tell you straight when the answer is “leave it alone.”
What Types Of Siding Are Actually On Houses In Georgia?
Here’s what I run into, roughly from most common to least, across Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta:
- Hardboard siding — Masonite, LP, GP and similar. Wood fibers pressed together with resin. By far the most common thing I find on houses built from the late ’70s through the early 2000s.
- Vinyl siding. Plastic panels that lock together. Very common, and often it’s sitting on top of one of the others.
- Cedar. Real wood.
- Fiber cement. Cement, sand and cellulose fiber. On newer houses it’s become one of the most common products going up. Unfortunately, a lot of it went up wrong.
- T1-11. Wood panel siding, big in ’70s and ’80s houses. If yours is going soft at the bottom, here’s whether T1-11 can be repaired or covered over.
- Stucco and EIFS. A cement or synthetic finish over the wall.
- Aluminum. Fairly rare around here.
- Metal ag panels. The ribbed metal you see on barns, now showing up on houses with the barndominium craze.
Brick and stone aren’t technically siding — neither is stucco, really — but plenty of Georgia houses mix one of them with one of the above. You don’t need me to tell you what brick looks like.
One thing national “types of siding” articles never mention: a lot of houses here have two types at once. Vinyl over cedar. Vinyl over hardboard. Same house, two layers, and the one you can see isn’t the one that matters most. More on that below.
How Do I Tell If I Have Vinyl Siding?
Most people already know what vinyl looks like. But if you’re not sure, here’s what gives it away:
- It looks and feels like plastic. Push on a panel with your hand. If it gives a good bit, it’s vinyl. Nothing else on this list flexes like that.
- Look for J-channel. That’s a small piece of trim shaped like the letter J that catches the cut end of the siding. You’ll see it around windows and doors, and at the top of the wall under the soffit.
- Look at the bottom of the wall. On most of the house, vinyl runs all the way down and locks into an aluminum starter strip with no trim showing. Where the siding has to stop higher up — say around a deck — the installer cuts the bottom off and puts in a piece of J-channel to hold it.
- Metal-wrapped windows. Vinyl jobs usually wrap the window trim in aluminum.
- Mower and weed-eater damage. Little holes chipped out near the ground where a mower threw a rock, or a line chewed along the bottom row where the weed eater got too close. That kind of damage is a vinyl tell.
Aluminum looks a lot like vinyl, but it’s metal instead of plastic. Tap it with something metal — a key works — and you’ll hear a ting. Vinyl just thuds.
How Do I Tell If I Have Hardboard Siding Like Masonite Or LP?
Go to the bottom two or three rows of siding — the ones closest to the ground. That’s where hardboard tells on itself.
- Swelling. Boards puffed up past the nail heads, thicker at the bottom edge than at the top.
- Layers showing. On the worst boards you can see the bottom edge separating into layers, almost like wet cardboard.
- Exposed nail heads. Hardboard here was almost always face nailed, meaning nails driven straight through the face of the board where you can see them.
- Crumbling at the corners and joints.
If you see swelling at the bottom rows, you almost certainly have hardboard. Here’s why Masonite siding crumbles, and what’s usually behind it. If you want to know which hardboard — LP, GP or Masonite — I go through that in Is It LP, GP or Masonite? How to Tell What’s Actually on Your House.
Why Does My Fiber Cement Look Like It’s Failing?
This one’s worth slowing down for, because it’s the one that surprises people.
Fiber cement installed wrong shows a lot of the same symptoms as hardboard: exposed face nails, corners chipped off at the joints, broken boards, and the face of the board peeling off in layers. Some boards crack with a vertical line right down the middle.
The difference is that it doesn’t swell. Hardboard soaks up water and puffs up. Fiber cement doesn’t. So if your house has all the damage above but the bottom rows are still flat and the same thickness as the rest of the wall, you’re most likely looking at fiber cement that was installed incorrectly. Hardie board or hardboard? Here’s how to tell what’s actually falling apart.
That’s not a knock on the product. Fiber cement is what I install, and installed correctly I think it’s the best product on the market. But it’s heavy, it’s brittle, and it doesn’t forgive a crew that’s in a hurry. When it fails, it’s almost always because of how it went up. I go deep on that in Watch the Nails and Seven Things You Can See From Your Driveway That Say Your Siding Was Installed Wrong.
How Do I Tell Cedar, T1-11, Stucco And Metal Panels Apart?
Cedar is usually a lot thicker than hardboard. It won’t swell at the bottom the way hardboard does. It has a true wood grain to it — not a stamped pattern that repeats every few feet. And the giveaway I see constantly: knots that have fallen out and left a hole in the board.
T1-11 looks like big sheets of plywood with a grooved channel running top to bottom, usually 8 inches apart. It reads like board and batten, but backwards — the grooves are cut in instead of the battens sticking out. It’s wood, it soaks up a lot of paint, and it takes a lot of maintenance to keep it looking good. You’ll mostly find it on ’70s and ’80s houses.
Stucco looks like one big wall of mortar with sand in it. Installers used different patterns and finishes, so it won’t all look the same. What matters is the damage. If you see cracks, or a section that seems to bow out from the wall, or chunks of the finish missing, look at what’s showing underneath:
- Foam board showing usually means EIFS — synthetic stucco applied over foam insulation.
- Wire mesh showing usually means traditional hard-coat stucco.
Either way, that’s one I’d have looked at. More on why below.
Metal ag panels are the long, ribbed metal panels screwed straight to the wall. If your house looks like a very nice barn, that’s what you’ve got.
Is There Old Siding Hiding Under My Vinyl?
This is the check I’d do first if you have vinyl. It’s the one that tells you what you can’t see.
Walk up to a window and look at the trim. On a house with one layer of siding, the vinyl and its J-channel sit back near the window trim. If the window trim sits further in than the vinyl — like the siding is sticking out past the window — the wall got thicker at some point. That usually means the vinyl went on over the old siding.
Then find your outside water spigot. The plumbing is where it’s always been. Nobody moved it when they re-sided. So if the hose bib looks like it’s sunk into the wall, with the vinyl built up around it, that’s the same story: two layers.
Two more ways to check:
- Look at the bottom edge of the vinyl. Sometimes you can see the edge of the old siding right behind it.
- Push on the vinyl in the middle of a wall. Sometimes you can feel the old siding’s lap behind it — a ridge where the boards underneath overlap.
The push test doesn’t always work, and here’s why. A lot of installers nailed a thin foam board called fanfold over the old siding to flatten out the wall, then put the vinyl on top of that. The foam fills in the ridges, so you can’t feel them. If the window and spigot say two layers and the push test says one, trust the window and the spigot.
Why does this matter? I’ve seen too many houses with multiple layers that had rot behind them, and the homeowners never knew. Water gets behind the vinyl, gets trapped against the old siding, and sits there. I wrote a whole post on this: Can You Install New Siding Over Old Siding?
Which Types Of Siding Can I Live With, And Which Mean Start Saving?
Here’s where each one lands, the way I’d tell you on the phone.
Cedar: you can live with it, if you keep up with it. Painted or stained every year or two and kept free of bugs, cedar will last for years. What I see constantly is homeowners who didn’t know how much maintenance real wood needs, and it becomes a nightmare before they know it. If you just bought a house with cedar in good shape — fresh coat, no woodpecker holes in the chimney — keep it that way and you probably won’t have to replace it for a long time.
But be honest with yourself about the maintenance. Over enough years, the money you spend keeping wood up will likely outweigh the cost of replacing it. So it comes down to which headache do you want to deal with? An ongoing one, or one today that fixes it — and then you don’t think about paint for 5 to 7 years, or 15-plus with a factory finish like ColorPlus.
T1-11: same question as cedar. It’s a maintenance choice. If it’s crumbling along the bottom, it’s probably time to start thinking about replacing it.
Hardboard: start setting money aside. If you’ve got exposed nail heads and boards that are swelling, breaking or crumbling, it’s time to start saving. That doesn’t mean this month. It means start planning.
Vinyl: get it checked for a second layer. Vinyl itself isn’t an emergency. But if the window or spigot check above says two layers, it’s worth having somebody look at what’s behind it. Not a replace-it-immediately situation. A start-planning one.
Fiber cement installed wrong: more serious than it looks. Cracked boards are the part you can see. What worries me more is what you can’t: trim installed without proper weather cuts, no flashing behind the joints, missing kick-out flashing where the roofline and gutters meet the siding, and missing flashing over the tops of windows and doors. Those last two can be the biggest problems on this whole list. Water follows the path of least resistance, it’ll find its way inside, and it damages the framing.
And in my experience, if the things you can see are wrong, there’s a lot more wrong that you can’t see without a trained eye. You can repair it. In the end, though, you’d almost always be better off fixing everything at once. Which headache — now, or later?
Stucco and EIFS: don’t let this one sit. If you have any cracks, get it checked. If bugs are getting into the house and you can’t figure out how, get it checked. Stucco is the one type on this list I wouldn’t wait on. If it’s cracking or bowing, there’s probably a pretty big issue going on behind it.
Aluminum: probably fine, but probably no housewrap. It’s uncommon here, and most customers who have it call us because they want a different look or better energy efficiency, not because it’s failing. If it’s aluminum, there’s a good chance there’s no housewrap behind it.
Metal ag panels: usually fine. The thing to watch is the rubber washers under the screw heads. When those dry rot, the screw holes can let water in.
Why Would A Fiber Cement Contractor Tell You His Own Product Fails?
Because it does, when it’s put up wrong, and you’re going to see it on houses whether I mention it or not.
I’ll also be straight about something else. On a couple of these types — wrongly installed fiber cement especially — I’m telling you full replacement is usually the better answer, and full replacement is what I sell. I know how that sounds. So here’s my test for whether I’m just selling you: on cedar, T1-11, aluminum and metal panels, I’m telling you that you can probably leave it alone. On vinyl, I’m telling you to check, not to replace. That’s most of the list.
And if you go get it checked and the answer is “you’re fine,” that’s a good outcome. I’d rather you hear that from somebody than spend money twice.
What I’d Tell You If You Called Me
- Do the window and spigot check today if you have vinyl. It takes two minutes and it’s the best way to find out if there’s something behind it.
- Look at your bottom three rows. Swelling means hardboard. Damage without swelling means fiber cement that probably went up wrong.
- Don’t sit on cracked or bowing stucco. Everything else on this list can usually wait while you save. Stucco usually shouldn’t.
- If you have wood siding, decide which headache you want. Keeping it up is a fine choice. Just make it on purpose.
- Don’t let anybody rush you. Outside of stucco and active leaks inside the house, you almost always have time to save, get a couple of opinions, and make a decision you’re comfortable with.
Not Sure What You’re Looking At?
Call us and we’ll talk you through what you’re seeing — even if the answer is “leave it alone.” And if you already have a siding quote in hand, our Free Risk Report will walk you through what’s included, what isn’t, and what risks come with it.
There’s a good feeling in pulling into your driveway and knowing exactly what’s on your house and what’s behind it — instead of wondering every time it rains.
Live in or around Atlanta? Start with our siding contractor page for Atlanta, which lays out real Metro Atlanta prices.
Related reading: What’s the Best Siding for a Georgia House? · Fiber Cement vs Vinyl Siding · Siding Cost in Middle Georgia

Thomas Williams is co-founder of All American Renovations, which he and his brother Pete started as a gutter business in 2001 and have run in Henry County, Georgia, for 25 years. He has installed James Hardie siding since 2007 and writes the company’s Learning Center. All American Renovations is an Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE, a CertainTeed ShingleMaster and an EPA Lead-Safe Certified Firm. Read Thomas’s full profile or connect with Thomas on LinkedIn.
