Is LP Siding Really That Bad? An Honest Review

Thomas Williams, All American Renovations – Elite member of James Hardie™ ALLIANCE · Metro Atlanta and Middle Georgia


Mostly, no — and most of the LP SmartSide problems people read about are attached to the wrong thing. The LP that’s failing on Georgia houses is an older generation of the product, not what’s sold today — and most of what I see go wrong traces back to how it was nailed on rather than what it’s made of.

I should also tell you up front: I have never installed a single board of LP siding. I’ve torn hundreds of houses of it off.

What Am I Actually Qualified To Tell You?

This matters, so let’s be clear about it.

An installer can tell you how a product goes on. I can’t tell you that about LP. What I can tell you is how it looks twenty and thirty years later, because that’s the only version of it I ever meet — usually the week we’re taking it off.

That’s a narrower view than it sounds, and it’s also a view no installer has. I see outcomes. I don’t see the install.

So take everything here as what a tear-off contractor sees, not as a product test.

Which LP Do You Actually Have?

Here’s the part most homeowners have never had explained: the engineered wood siding that went on Georgia houses in the eighties and nineties is not the same product line sold under that name today. The older generation is what I meet on tear-offs — it absorbed moisture, swelled, and went soft at the edges. The current product is a different formulation and good contractors install it today.

And now the honest part: on a tear-off, I can’t tell them apart. The engineered wood I pull off all looks the same to me by the time I get to it, and it’s essentially always face-nailed. So I can’t sit here and tell you I’ve proven anything about today’s product, because I couldn’t tell you I’ve ever had it in my hands.

Anybody who uses thirty-year-old failed siding as evidence against today’s product is stretching. That includes me, which is why I’m not doing it.

So Why Is It Falling Apart?

Short version, because I’ve written about this at length elsewhere: face nailing.

Every house I’ve opened up had the siding nailed straight through the face. Siding moves with the seasons. A face nail won’t let it. The caulk around those nail heads fails, water gets in, and the board starts delaminating from the bottom edge up. Ten years of that and the paint is about the only thing holding it together.

By the time I’m looking at it, it’s cardboard with a texture on it. But it didn’t have to end that way.

Is It Only LP, Or That Whole Era Of Siding?

I’m not the only one seeing this, and I’d rather you heard it from somebody who doesn’t replace siding for a living.

Chris Brown runs Georgia Home Inspection Services. He inspects houses for buyers — he has no product to sell and no reason to flatter anybody in my trade. I asked him what he runs into:

“Another siding material I come across fairly often in my inspections is Masonite or hardboard siding, which was commonly installed on homes in the 1980s and 1990s. I frequently find swelling, deterioration, and moisture damage at the lower edges, joints, and other vulnerable areas, especially where flashing, clearances, or maintenance have been inadequate.”

Chris Brown, Georgia Home Inspection Services

Notice we’re describing the same thing from two completely different angles. He’s on a ladder with a flashlight before somebody buys the house; I’m there with a pry bar the week it comes off. We both start at the bottom edge.

Notice something else, too: he names three causes and one of them is maintenance. I’ve been telling you this is an installation problem, and mostly I believe that. But he’s right, and it’s fair to say so — a wall that never got painted and never got its caulk looked at is going to fail sooner than the same wall that did, whoever hung it.

And LP was one brand in a whole category. Masonite, hardboard, engineered wood products under several names — a lot of Georgia houses from that era have something in this family on them, and a lot of homeowners call all of it “LP” the same way they call all fiber cement “Hardie.” If you want to know which one is on your wall, I walk through it in Is It LP, GP or Masonite?

Is LP A Bad Product, Honestly?

No — and I’d say that even though I make my living replacing it with something else.

Installed correctly and maintained, LP is an okay product. It’s lighter than fiber cement, which makes it easier and cheaper to hang. Those are real advantages and I’m not going to pretend otherwise.

The failures I see aren’t a verdict on the material. They’re a verdict on the installation. And I know that because I see the identical failure on badly installed James Hardie — face nail Hardie instead of blind nailing into the studs and you get the same loose boards, the same delamination, the same wall.

What’s on your house matters a lot less than whether whoever hung it followed the manual.

What About LP SmartSide Problems Today?

Here’s where I have to stop being useful, and I’d rather say so than guess.

If you are comparing LP SmartSide to fiber cement for a new job, I wrote that up separately: engineered wood siding or fiber cement.

I don’t have much direct experience with modern SmartSide. I’ve been around it a little. I’m not going to review a product I haven’t worked with.

What I can tell you is this: every engineered wood and fiber cement product on the market has its own written installation requirements, and if a contractor doesn’t follow the ones for the product on your wall, you’ll have problems with it — exactly like you will with a badly installed fiber cement wall.

One thing about our market worth knowing: when Atlanta moved away from LP, it moved to fiber cement rather than to newer engineered wood. So around here, LP isn’t really the comparison most homeowners are weighing anymore. The live question is which fiber cement, which is a different post.

What I’d Tell You If You Called Me

  • Find out what you have and roughly when it went on. A house sided in the eighties or nineties almost certainly has the old generation on it — and it might not be LP at all. Masonite and other hardboards went on plenty of houses in the same years.
  • Look at the bottom edges and the joints first. That’s where an inspector looks and it’s where I find it. Swelling, softness, layers separating.
  • Don’t judge today’s LP by what’s on your 1988 house. Different product, and I can’t prove otherwise from a tear-off.
  • Look at how it’s nailed before you blame the material. That’s where the answer usually is.
  • If it’s failing, it’s failing. The why matters less than the water getting in.
  • Ask your contractor about install method, not just brand. It’s the thing that actually determines how long your wall lasts.

Not Sure What’s On Your House?

If you’re in Middle Georgia or Metro Atlanta and you’re looking at siding you can’t identify, get on the phone with me. I’ll tell you what I think you’ve got and what shape it’s likely in — and if you’ve got time before you need to do anything, I’ll tell you that too.

Already know it needs replacing? Here’s what that costs around here. Wondering if it can just be repaired? Here’s the honest answer.

Sources: Chris Brown, Georgia Home Inspection Services · James Hardie installation instructions and technical documents. Everything else on this page is what we see on our own tear-offs in Middle Georgia and Metro Atlanta. We do not install engineered wood siding and make no claim about how today’s products perform.

Scroll to Top